18-Wheeler Rollover Shuts Down I-35 Near Von Ormy on October 19

Von Ormy Rollover Puts Nuclear Verdict Trucking Laws in Focus

Key Takeaways: An 18-wheeler rollover shut down I-35 near Von Ormy on October 19, which again shows how dangerous commercial trucks are on San Antonio’s Southwest Side. Under Chapter 72 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, a rollover that injures people can count as a "collision" even if the truck never hit another vehicle. Since 2021, Texas has used special trial rules in trucking cases, adopted in response to nuclear verdict concerns, that let a trucking company ask for a two-phase trial. A company may admit the driver was its employee to limit some claims, but claims that do not depend on the driver’s negligence, such as negligent maintenance, can still go forward. Under Texas’s proportionate responsibility rule, victims can still recover unless they are more than 50 percent at fault, and punitive damages usually require clear and convincing evidence of fraud, malice, or gross negligence. Victims with catastrophic injuries and grieving families should act quickly to preserve evidence and understand these rules before they talk to any insurer.

The October 19 I-35 closure near Von Ormy was more than a traffic problem. When a fully loaded 18-wheeler rolls over, tens of thousands of pounds of steel and cargo can crush passenger vehicles, spill debris across lanes, and cause deadly secondary crashes. Investigators had not released full details of this incident when we published this article. For families on the Southwest Side and across Bexar County, it raises an urgent question: if a rollover like this changes your life, how does Texas law decide who pays?

Department of Public Safety officer directing traffic beside patrol car with flashing lights

How Texas Rewrote the Rules for Commercial Truck Accident Cases

In 2021, Texas passed House Bill 19, which created special trial rules for lawsuits over commercial truck crashes. The rules appear in Chapter 72 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code. They apply to civil actions seeking damages for bodily injury or death caused by a collision involving a commercial motor vehicle. A "commercial motor vehicle" is a vehicle used for business in interstate or intrastate commerce to carry property or passengers, deliver goods, or provide services. A loaded 18-wheeler on I-35 generally fits that definition.

The definitions matter a great deal in a rollover case. Under § 72.051, "collision" means any event in which operating a commercial truck causes bodily injury or death. The statute’s definition of operating a truck includes situations where the truck is stopped, parked, or disabled. As a result, an overturned semi on I-35 that injures people may fall under these rules even if it never struck another vehicle, although how the definition applies depends on the facts.

Why Lawmakers Targeted Nuclear Verdict Trucking Cases

The trucking industry pushed for these rules after a series of very large jury awards, often called "nuclear verdicts." The split trial process is one of Texas’s main legislative responses to nuclear verdict trucking concerns. Supporters say it keeps juries focused. Victims’ advocates point out that the rules can make it harder to put a carrier’s broader safety record in front of the jury at the right moment. Families who understand this structure are better prepared to push back.

When a Rollover Shatters a San Antonio Family

Picture a mother driving home on I-35 near Von Ormy when a jackknifing trailer tips over into her lane. Her sedan is crushed. She survives with a traumatic brain injury and a spinal cord injury that may leave her permanently unable to work. Within days, the carrier’s insurer calls. The adjuster suggests that her speed played a role and that the driver alone was responsible. This scenario is hypothetical, but families facing the aftermath of an I-35 18-wheeler rollover often hear the same tactics.

Every one of those moves connects to a specific Texas statute. Blaming her speed points to proportionate responsibility. Blaming the driver alone may set up a corporate stipulation under Chapter 72. Knowing this early can help a family protect evidence and avoid statements that insurers may later use against them.

The Two-Phase Trial and What It Means for Victims

If the trucking company asks, the court must divide the trial into two phases under § 72.052. In the first phase, the jury decides fault and compensatory damages. In the second phase, it decides exemplary (punitive) damages, if they are sought. The defendant must generally make the request by the later of 120 days after filing its original answer or 30 days after the injured person files a pleading adding a new claim or party.

What Jurors Can Still Hear in Phase One

The split does not automatically keep safety evidence out of the first phase. Under § 72.054, evidence of the driver’s or company’s compliance with certain federal motor carrier rules (49 C.F.R. Parts 382, 383, 390, 391, 392, and 395) or Texas Transportation Code Chapter 644 may be admissible in phase one if it is otherwise relevant and admissible. That evidence can include:

  • Whether the driver held the proper license or was disqualified or under an out-of-service order
  • Whether the driver had a valid medical certificate
  • Whether the driver exceeded hours-of-service limits
  • Whether the driver was texting or using a handheld phone
  • Whether the company allowed the driver to work in violation of hours-of-service or drug-testing rules
  • Whether the company properly checked the driver’s background

Texas also requires safe loading. Under Transportation Code § 644.051, the public safety director must adopt rules, consistent with federal rules, to make sure commercial trucks are safely maintained, equipped, loaded, and operated. The word "loaded" may become central if investigators find that a cargo shift contributed to the Von Ormy truck crash.

Claims That Survive a Corporate Admission

A trucking company may try to limit its exposure by admitting the driver was its employee. Under § 72.054(a), if the company makes a timely stipulation that the driver was its employee acting within the scope of the job, it is liable for the driver’s negligence only through the employer liability doctrine called respondeat superior, and the injured person generally may not pursue claims such as negligent hiring, entrustment, training, or supervision in phase one. Carriers often use this approach when they want to argue that the driver alone caused the crash.

That admission does not end every claim against the company. Section 72.054 preserves claims that do not depend on the driver’s negligence, such as negligent maintenance, and those claims may be presented in phase one. Victims may also still seek punitive damages for the company’s own conduct in phase two. In addition, if the jury finds the driver negligent in phase one, the injured person may present evidence on claims such as negligent entrustment in phase two in support of exemplary damages.

Fault, Gross Negligence, and Truck Rollover Liability in Texas

Texas uses a modified comparative fault system called proportionate responsibility. Under § 33.001, a claimant may not recover damages if their share of responsibility is greater than 50 percent. If a claimant is partly at fault but at or below that threshold, their recovery is reduced by their percentage of fault. This is why insurers so often try to shift blame onto victims.

Punitive damages require a higher standard of proof. Under § 41.003, exemplary damages generally require clear and convincing evidence of fraud, malice, or gross negligence, and the jury’s finding must be unanimous. Texas defines gross negligence under § 41.001 as an act or omission involving an extreme degree of risk, where the actor actually knew of the risk but went ahead with conscious indifference to others’ safety. Proving that standard is fact-intensive. Chapter 41 also generally caps punitive damages, and a company is not automatically liable for punitive damages based only on its driver’s conduct.

Evidence That Can Disappear Quickly

An 18-wheeler crash investigation should begin before critical data is lost. Key evidence can include ELD and black-box data, maintenance and inspection records, the driver’s employment and training files, weight tickets, and bills of lading. Federal rules require carriers to keep some of these records for only limited periods, such as six months for certain hours-of-service records. Prompt preservation letters can make a significant difference in what evidence remains available.

How Does This Impact Me?

Does Chapter 72 Apply if the Truck Never Hit My Car?

Possibly. Because § 72.051 defines "collision" as any event in which operating a commercial truck causes bodily injury or death, a rollover that injures people may qualify even without direct impact. Whether it applies to you depends on the specific facts of your crash.

Can I Still Recover if the Insurer Says I Was Partly at Fault?

In many cases, yes. Under § 33.001, you may recover as long as your responsibility is not greater than 50 percent, although your damages would be reduced by your share of fault. How fault is divided is often heavily contested.

What Is My Deadline to File?

Texas generally allows two years to file personal injury and wrongful death claims, subject to limited exceptions. Wrongful death claims usually run from the date of death. Those exceptions are narrow and do not apply automatically. If a government entity was involved, for example in road maintenance, the Texas Tort Claims Act generally requires written notice within six months, and some cities set even shorter deadlines.

What Should My Family Do Right Now?

Get complete medical care and document every injury and expense. Avoid giving recorded statements to the carrier’s insurer. Speak with a trucking attorney who can act quickly to preserve electronic and maintenance evidence.

Standing With Victims After the Von Ormy Truck Crash

The October 19 rollover is a reminder that Texas trucking law is complex, and carriers understand it well. Two-phase trials, corporate stipulations, and proportionate responsibility rules can all shape what a family recovers after a catastrophic injury or wrongful death. Paula Wyatt has been recognized as a Top 10 Trucking Trial Lawyer and has decades of experience taking on corporate defendants and insurers. A nuclear verdict trucking lawyer with that background can help families understand their options, although every outcome depends on the specific facts. To discuss your situation, call 210-340-5550 or contact us today.