Top
Over $1 Billion Recovered For Injury Victims Get A Fighter On Your Side Today
  • Multi-Million Dollar Advocates
  • National Women Trial Lawyers, Top 25
  • The National Trial Lawyers
  • American Academy of Attorneys, 500 Million Dollar Club
  • Super Lawyers, 2026
  • American Academy of Attorneys, Top 100
  • AV Preeminent
  • Top 10, Trucking Trial Lawyers
  • Best Law Firms 2025

9 Tips For Your First Call With Insurance Company After An Accident

Getting in an accident is traumatizing enough, but facing the prospect of speaking to an insurance company after may seem like the stressful cherry on top of a terrible cake. No matter how daunting the prospect may seem, communicating with your insurance company after an accident is a vital part of the claims process. With these nine tips, hopefully you’ll feel more prepared to tackle the task at hand. 

1.Call the Police Immediately After the Collision: As long as you aren’t in need of immediate medical attention, call the police as soon after the collision as possible. An official accident report will help you provide the necessary information to your insurance company.

2.Take Pictures: Take pictures of the scene of the accident before anything is moved. Focus on the damage to your vehicle, and any debris that may be on the road. This documentation can be very useful later when you try to settle your claim.

3.Document Everything: The insurance company may want to handle your case over the phone, so it’s important to take notes throughout your conversation. This will help you keep track of the progress of your claim as well as serve as a good way to organize your thoughts.

4.Be Proactive: Don’t wait for your insurance company to tell you how much you’re entitled to in your claim; ask. Be sure to provide them with proof of your losses through documentation, both written and photographic.

5.Make Sure You Have A Paper Trail: Along with documenting your conversations, be sure to send a follow up email confirming promises and guarantees made in person or over the phone. Having physical proof will be important in getting the most out of your claim.

6.A Friendly Voice Doesn’t Mean They’re A Friend: Remember, this is a business negotiation. Just because the voice on the other end of the line may sound friendly doesn’t mean they’re actually your friend. It’s part of their job as a customer service representative to be friendly, but they still work for the insurance company.

7.Keep A Good Attitude: Again, you’re speaking with a customer service representative. It’s their job to be a point of contact for the insurance company, and they won’t be able to change the world for you. Being polite can’t change the fact that you were in an accident, but it can make working with the insurance company much smoother.

8.Be Careful Signing Any Papers: Insurance companies may attempt to pressure you into accepting a quick settlement and signing a liability release. Chances are, they’re only offering you a portion of what you’re eligible to receive. Once you sign on the dotted line, you won’t be able to change your mind, even if the damage was far more severe than originally estimated.

9.Contact an Attorney: Car accident attorneys have spent their lives training to deal with insurance companies. It’s their job to get you the best settlement for which you’re eligible.

At the Wyatt Law Firm, we are dedicated to protecting your rights and making sure that insurance companies don’t take advantage of you. We accept personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning that you don’t need to worry about attorney fees unless we win. If you’re looking for a car accident lawyer in the San Antonio area, contact us today to schedule your free case evaluation.

You're about to use our sticky note tool to submit website requests to our team. Click the "Accept" button to download a cookie that will authorize you to see and use the tool on this device.


To leave a Sticky note, click the comment button and then click anywhere on the page.

0 Comment
    Aggressive and passionate
    “Ms. Wyatt fought hard for me and kept me informed and ultimately got me an excellent settlement. I would definitely recommend her to anyone involved in a commercial vehicle accident or work related injury accident.”
    - Former Client
    So many thanks to you, Paula and all Your Staff. God bless.
    “With all the pain and suffering, it was a comfort knowing that my family and I were being taken care of. Again, so many thanks to you, Paula and all your Staff. God bless.”
    - Nora L.
    Great job to the Wyatt Law Firm for the outstanding job you’ve done.
    “I want to give thanks for the incredible job you and your staff provided for us. First of all to Paula, you were outstanding for your consistency and support throughout the years.”
    - Paul Z.
    The Wyatt Law Firm is hands down the best law firm in San Antonio, TX.
    “Paula will fight for your justice! She will not stop until she gets the outcome you desire. If you are in need of an attorney don’t hesitate to give them a call you won’t regret it!”
    - Diana D.
    I highly recommend Wyatt Law Firm
    “I highly recommend Wyatt law firm not only for their experience but the dedication they have toward their client. I felt really comfortable having them handle my case.”
    - Maria E.M.
    God bless you and thank you for all of your hard work.
    “We are just so grateful that this matter is behind us and we have The Wyatt Law Firm to thank. Once again, God bless you and thank you for all of your hard work.”
    - Adrianna Z.
    The whole Wyatt Law Firm is such a comforting group of special people
    “I want to express my deepest appreciation to the Wyatt Law Firm for all of the hard work that was put forth on my behalf. In the beginning, I was so worried, but Paula and James made me feel so very special – almost like I was the only case they had.”
    - Nancy L.
    Wyatt Law Firm truly is the best Law Firm in San Antonio.
    “Wyatt Law Firm truly is the best Law Firm in San Antonio. Took care of everything I needed and changed my life for the better.”
    - Alexa L.
    Fantastic lawyers in a nationally-respected law firm.
    “Fantastic lawyers in a nationally-respected law firm. These folks are the best!”
    - Robert F.

Real People, Real Outcomes

Our Client Testimonials

When The System Isn't Fair,

We Fight Back
  • By submitting, you agree to receive text messages from Wyatt Law Firm, PLLC at the number provided, including those related to your inquiry, follow-ups, and review requests, via automated technology. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency may vary. Reply STOP to cancel or HELP for assistance. Acceptable Use Policy